
Since Routine Activity Theory's (RAT) notion of opportunity causing crime misunderstands that RAT's three components of opportunity are in fact a truism for every successful crime in commission 'opportunity' cannot be a cause of crime because it is an irrefutable and infinitely easy to vary truism. RAT opportunity is merely a precise description of the core components present at the successful crime scene in commission. This makes it the essential data of the crime. And data should not be confused with explanations for it. Religions typically confuse data with explanations. The tautological argument that the messages in the Christian Bible are all true because they are the word of God because the Bible is the word of God is a good example. Because, absurdly, the Bible is both the data and the only explanation required for the presence of the data. And so in this clip a hamster in a wheel gives us a lecture on the illogical circularity of RAT and Crime Science's unshaken belief in it. Professor, Reverend Hammy Wheel of the
An example of tautological reasoning (a logical fallacy)
Healthy Sceptic: Why do you think that the written Bible contains truth that the world was made in seven days?
Believer: Because the Bible is the written truth.
Healthy Sceptic: But how do you know that?
Believer: Because the Bible is the written word of God.
Healthy Sceptic: But you are not explaining why you think you know that it is the word of God.
Believer: In the Bible it is written that it is the word of God.
Healthy Sceptic: But how can you think you know that those words are true?
Believer: Because the Bible is the written truth.
Further thoughts
Is it better to seek to understand rather than ridicule? Does the video of the Rev. Wheel giving a squeaky voiced lecture whilst going around in his wheel serve as a useful heuristic device for explaining why something is a logical fallacy? More on that debate can be had here. And a detailed academic debunking of the fallacy that opportunity makes the thief can be had here.
4 comments:
You need to tell plod. I was on a police blog (don't worry I washed my hands after) and they do not seem to have a clue. Not a Scooby Doo! Happy Xmas from Burberry wearing Ferret admirers everywhere!
Dear reverend Hammy Wheel. Thank you for this sermon. It made my Christmas. I wonder what your thoughts are on whether Felson and Cohen, Clarke and Laycock and other founders of the Church of Crime Science have escaped from their superior and more mature intellectual and properly educated sociological and social scientific and scientific academic handlers?
Dear Barry
That does fit what RAT has to say about the scene of every successful crime in action. Therefore, it must logically fit the RAT advent.
Are you saying there are professors who think this tautology is meaningful? Are they just plain dumb or what!!!!! http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_zE8CzamN1Y0/TSQ0RqWocTI/AAAAAAAABnU/Q9q9P07wd_c/s1600/rat%2Btriad.JPG
Post a Comment